{"contract_version":"web-product-v1","provenance":{"source_url":"https://www.indyturk.com/node/784996/t%C3%BCrki%CC%87yeden-sesler/din-ve-devlet","content_hash":"a68f4bbc50cbf27e5b401bdb84550ee58d7a8ee777e7a012b0af0b1de879a787","story_version":1,"source_revision":null,"source_revision_status":"NOT_RECORDED_IN_PUBLIC_STORY_SCHEMA","publication_updated_at":"2026-11-10T09:07:39Z","published_at":"2026-11-10T05:00:00+00:00","hash_scope":"RECORDED_ARCHIVE_HASH_NOT_VERIFIED_ORIGINAL_BYTES"},"corrections":{"status":"PENDING_EVIDENCE","versions":[],"reason":"PUBLIC_CORRECTION_PUBLICATION_CONTRACT_REQUIRED"},"living_event":{"status":"PENDING_EVIDENCE","sources":[],"claims":[],"evidence":[],"counterevidence":[],"timeline":[],"uncertainty":[],"relations":[],"reason":"AUTHORIZED_PUBLIC_CHILD_PUBLICATION_CONTRACT_REQUIRED"},"analysis":{"contract_version":"web-product-v1","status":"PENDING_EVIDENCE","sections":[],"required_section_count":12,"section_slots":[{"section_id":1,"status":"MISSING_APPROVED_REPORT_DATA"},{"section_id":2,"status":"MISSING_APPROVED_REPORT_DATA"},{"section_id":3,"status":"MISSING_APPROVED_REPORT_DATA"},{"section_id":4,"status":"MISSING_APPROVED_REPORT_DATA"},{"section_id":5,"status":"MISSING_APPROVED_REPORT_DATA"},{"section_id":6,"status":"MISSING_APPROVED_REPORT_DATA"},{"section_id":7,"status":"MISSING_APPROVED_REPORT_DATA"},{"section_id":8,"status":"MISSING_APPROVED_REPORT_DATA"},{"section_id":9,"status":"MISSING_APPROVED_REPORT_DATA"},{"section_id":10,"status":"MISSING_APPROVED_REPORT_DATA"},{"section_id":11,"status":"MISSING_APPROVED_REPORT_DATA"},{"section_id":12,"status":"MISSING_APPROVED_REPORT_DATA"}],"source_story":{"story_id":182848,"version":1,"content_hash":"a68f4bbc50cbf27e5b401bdb84550ee58d7a8ee777e7a012b0af0b1de879a787"},"approved_heading_mapping":"PENDING_EVIDENCE","depth":null,"reason":"APPROVED_ANALYSIS_PUBLICATION_AND_HEADING_CONTRACT_REQUIRED"},"story":{"story_id":182848,"title":"Din ve devlet","summary":"İmam Ali’nin hilafeti \"nas\" (atama) ile mi, \"nasb\" (tayin) ile mi gerçekleşti? Şayet \"nas\" iledir dersek, diğerlerinin hilafeti batıl olur. Şayet \"nasb\" (tayin) iledir dersek, o takdirde 14 asırdır ümmeti yiyip bitiren bu tefrikaya son vermiş oluruz. Daha doğrusu, ümmeti içinde bulunduğu bu durumdan kurtarmanın yolu, kanaatimce mezheple ilgili meseleleri, bir mezhep fedaisi gibi değil, aynen bir akademisyen gibi tarafsızca ele alıp akademik izahatta bulunmaktan geçer. İran’daki inkılaptan sonra ","category":"dunya","country":"iran","published_at":"2026-11-10T05:00:00+00:00","source_url":"https://www.indyturk.com/node/784996/t%C3%BCrki%CC%87yeden-sesler/din-ve-devlet","language":"tr","status":"PUBLISHED","version":1,"content_hash":"a68f4bbc50cbf27e5b401bdb84550ee58d7a8ee777e7a012b0af0b1de879a787","subcategory":"","image_url":"https://www.indyturk.com/sites/default/files/article/main_image/2026/11/10/1383485-1481442114.jpg","publication_updated_at":"2026-11-10T09:07:39Z","degree":"D4","source_language_status":"KNOWN","masa_classification_status":"RECORDED","spam_assessment_status":"RECORDED","source_language":"tr"},"entities":[],"related":[],"timeline":[],"evidence_visibility":"PENDING_PUBLICATION_CONTRACT","living_event_status":"PENDING_AUTHORIZED_API_CONTRACT"}